Russia’s Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes

I’ve been pretty vocal about how Russia has seemingly embraced the crytpocurrency craze.  In announcement after announcement this year it looked like the state apparatus in Russia under President Vladimir Putin’s direction would be at the forefront of seeing the opportunities for Russia to utilize cryptocurrencies to avoid the worst of the hostility coming from the U.S.

With the draft legislation put forth by the the Russian Ministry of Finance this week those hopes look to be dashed.

The ‘Crypto-Ruble’ we discussed at great length over the summer?  Nixed.

Integrating cryptocurrencies into day-to-day Russian life?  Nope.

Regulation of miners and mining as taxable profits?  Yes.

In short, this draft legislation is about as hostile to cryptocurrencies as it could possibly have been.  And it betrays who still has out-sized control over the Russian economy and state-apparatus.

And it has been coming for a couple of years.  It finally took Putin demanding they put a draft together by the end of this year to get something from them.  Deputy Finance Minister Alexei Mosieev has been very hostile to Bitcoin and the legislation is a reflection of this.

And, for the life of me, I have to wonder what he’s thinking when it is obvious that Putin wanted something far more progressive than this backwards looking bill.

For all of the talk about how Putin runs Russia with an iron fist for his own enrichment, it was he who pushed for regulations and legislation to be drafted. And for the MoF to come back with this along with the Bank of Russia’s blessing is telling.

I’ve always heard that it is the Russian banking system and the politicians connected to it that are the real Fifth Column within Russia that Putin has yet to get under full control.  The Bank of Russia’s adherence to  IMF-style austerity in the wake of the ruble crisis in 2014 has made this clear.

Bank of Russia President Elvira Nabullina had to be privately dressed down (I suspect) by Putin himself in March before she would finally relent and begin lowering interest rates from 10% which were obviously strangling the Russian economy.

Today rates stand at 7.75% and they are still way too high, if the Russian yield curve is any indication.

It’s almost like the Bank of Russia is trying to keep the Russian economy puttering along on the edge of recession in the lead up to March’s elections.

These draft rules on cryptocurrencies were obviously put together by backwards-thinking oligarchs who owe their allegiance more to Wall St. and The Square Mile than they do Russia.

To give you an idea of how stupid these rules are.  Russians would be allowed to own cryptocurrencies but they wouldn’t be allowed to use them for anything.  They obviously want to protect the status of the ruble as the only settlement currency but at the same time the biggest issue in Russia is the existence of a parallel dollar-based banking system.

This has been the primary complaint of Stolypin Group Leader Sergei Glazyev who has been very vocal in his condemnation of how the Bank of Russia and the MoF have not closed loopholes to the flow of dollars through the Russian economy.

Glazyev spoke up recently on this issue saying very similar things to me; that cryptocurrencies would be a natural way for Russia to fight further U.S. sanctions and attract capital into Russia that wants to flow in but legislative and regulatory hurdles prevent it.

For Putin he knows that Russia’s weakness is not its labor pool, its technological potential, or its physical capital.  Russia’s fundamental weakness, which was exploited to great effect in 2014 by the U.S. and the EU, is its financial system.

I’ve said this many times, what is holding the Russian economy back is a lack of professionalism in the way capital flows through the country.  Its banking system is, effectively, third world, and still corrupted by Western influences.

Ethereum and other ‘smart contract’ cryptocurrencies have the ability to help Russia leap frog from its current level of financial back office efficiency to surpass that of the West because so much of that back-office work involves the processing, clearing and archiving transactions which is inherent in the information contained on the blockchain.

The sanctions bill President Trump was forced to sign by John McCain and the rest of the neocon morons in the Senate has a provision that the Executive Branch must draw up a new list of Russian officials to sanction by February.  Also, it is expected that Trump will ban buying Russian government bonds by American investors.

All of this is timed to ensure maximal political damage is done to Putin on the eve of his re-election.  And now you also know why we’re sending weapons into Ukraine to intensify the conflict with the Donbass.

Moreover, as the Coindesk article linked above brings up, the basic hypocrisy of the bill is plain to see:

Following Moiseev’s announcement, experts told the publication that “the authorities will have to solve the most complicated task: to explain why you can pay for purchases with ‘bonuses’ on bank cards or ‘miles’, but cannot with bitcoin.” Economist Maxim Blunt commented:

Ways to circumvent these prohibitions are massive, can you pay with accumulated points in eateries or coffee shops? Then all of them should be on the bunk next to Gref.

The reference was to Sberbank’s president Herman Gref who publicly admitted that he bought a T-shirt using Bitcoin a few years ago. His bank also recently admitted to having bought almost all of the graphics cards on the Russian market but did not say whether they were using them for cryptocurrency mining.

The banking oligarchy is scared to death of cyrptocurrencies becoming true alternate payment.  Guys like Mosieev can do a lot of damage before they leave the scene.  With Putin running for re-election between now and March, it is things like this that he simply won’t have time for.

I expect the final version of this bill will look completely different than what the Mof, the Bank of Russia and Wall St. wants.

28 thoughts on “Russia’s Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes

  1. Is there any nation anywhere in the world where the financial economy is not run by globalist international bankers? And corporate internationalists.
    Check with USA President Wilson.

  2. The last Duma election gave Putin a constitutional majority. He hasn’t taken advantage of that yet which surprised me. However, it may be that it will take his own reelection to give him the kind of confidence he needs to use that majority.

    The Finance Ministry is run by Medvedev not Putin. Putin can dump Medvedev if (and when) he gets elected by a solid majority. And that means the exit of many of the fifth columnists in Medvedev’s entourage.

    The central bank is beholden to no other Russian state agency or governmental body. Changes to the latter take constitutional amendments.

    • Chew on this news a bit and contemplate the complexity of the s-ituation:

      “Major Russian bank will no longer service defense industry over US sanctions fears”


      Alfa-Bank, Russia’s seventh biggest by asset value, says it will phase out business contacts with internal defense enterprises to avoid falling foul of latest US sanctions which come into force this month.

      “These companies have been notified. It doesn’t mean that we are just closing down all accounts this moment. But we are trying to minimize risks,” Oleg Sysuev, deputy chair of Alfa-Bank’s board of directors, told the Ekho Moskvy radio station.

      Sysuev said defense companies represented a “significant part” of the bank’s credit portfolio. Last month, the bank’s founder, Mikhail Fridman, whose net worth is estimated at $16.2 billion by Forbes, told the magazine that Alfa-Bank was cutting ties with the Russia’s defense industry, saying, “What can we do?”

      Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin, who oversees Russia’s defense industry, offered an alternative explanation for Alfa-Bank’s decision.

      “I make no ethical judgement of the behavior of the Alfa-Bank board,” Rogozin wrote on his Facebook page. “But I will draw your attention to the fact that the bank asked for, and was refused, a license to operate with defense procurement funds.”

      In the comments section, Rogozin added that Alfa-Bank, Russia’s largest privately held financial institution, “wanted to make a good impression on the Americans.”

      The ‘Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act’ passed by Congress in July last year, stipulates separate sanctions on entities that have “significant transactions” with sanctioned Russian companies or individuals. A fresh list of sanctioned Russian companies, which include multiple defense enterprises, was published last October, with the new regulations taking effect on January 29, 2018.

      The battle of the insiders:

      “Putin Adviser Says ‘CryptoRuble’ Will Circumvent Sanctions, Government Remains Divided”


      At a recent government meeting, Sergei Glazyev, economic adviser to President Putin, said the ‘CryptoRuble’ could help alleviate the pressure of Western sanctions, The Financial Times reported Monday. However, there is still no unified official stance from the Russian government on the question of issuing a national digital currency.

      The Russian CryptoRuble is essentially a digital ruble — a government-issued digital currency accepted as legal tender.

      According to FT, Glazyev stated that a government-controlled cryptocurrency like the CryptoRuble would help Russia disregard Western sanctions:

      “This instrument suits us very well for sensitive activity on behalf of the state. We can settle accounts with our counterparties all over the world with no regard for sanctions.”

      A divided front:
      Glazyev’s positive stance on the CryptoRuble is the latest position in the ongoing back and forth on the topic within the Russian government.

      According to Russian news agency TASS, during a Dec. 28 meeting on legislation for digital currencies in Russia, government officials spoke negatively about the CryptoRuble.

      Both the Deputy Minister of Finance Alexey Moiseev and first Deputy Governor of Russia’s Central Bank, Olga Skorobogatova, stated that they did not see a need for issuing a national digital currency.

      However, in June 2017 at the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum, Skorobogatova held the opposite position, saying:

      “We will definitely get to a virtual national currency, we’ve already started working on it.”

      Not a new question:
      The Russian government has been publicly discussing the idea of a government-issued digital currency as legal tender as far back as 2015. Originally, Qiwi, a publicly traded Russian payment service provider, initiated the idea for a Russian national cryptocurrency called ‘BitRuble.’

      The Russian State Duma has an official working group in place that looks at cryptocurrency risks and regulations. Though there have been reports about possible outright cryptocurrency bans in Russia in the past, the government’s official stance remains unclear, leaning toward regulation of digital currency use.

      ‘The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean so many different things.’
      ‘The question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master — that’s all.’

      • The U.S. it putting direct pressure on Russian elected and appointed officials. And, as I’ve pointed out in the past, the finance industry is still riddled with folks whose loyalties lie outside of Russia.

        These new sanctions and the threat of the crypto-ruble is outing them for everyone to see. Expect many of them to be removed in the coming weeks/months.

        There was a reason why Putin fired Alexander Kudrin and hired Glazyev in 2016.

  3. Pingback: Russia’s Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes – The Snarky Report

  4. Pingback: Russia's Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes – TradingCheatSheet

  5. Pingback: Russia's Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes | ValuBit

  6. Pingback: Russia's Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes | ValuBitNews

  7. Pingback: Russia's Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes - Telzilla

  8. Pingback: Russia's Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes | StockTalk Journal

  9. Pingback: Russia's Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes | ProTradingResearch

  10. Pingback: Russia's Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes – Wall Street Karma

  11. Pingback: Russia’s Crypto Rules Betray Early Hopes - Investing Matters

  12. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? – Cryptocurrency News Feed

  13. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? – Daily Bitcoin Report

  14. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? | Cryptobase

  15. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? - Crypto Latest

  16. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? – Crypto-Monnaies : Toute l'actualité des Crypto-Monnaies !

  17. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? |

  18. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? – Crypto Currency Online

  19. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble?-Coinograph – 24anime1

  20. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? – Go Crypto

  21. Pingback: Rusya, Kripto-Ruble'yi Kucaklamış mı? | Bitcoin Haberleri

  22. Pingback: Will Russia Ever Embrace the Crypto-Ruble? - Bits N Alts

  23. Pingback: Russia’s Slow Walk to Financial Independence | Gold Goats 'n Guns

  24. Pingback: Russia's Clueless Central Bank Is Starving the Economy With Crazy High Interest Rates - Investing Matters

  25. Pingback: Russia's Clueless Central Bank Is Starving the Economy With Crazy High Interest Rates-Times of News Russia

Leave a Reply